Throughout my summer breaks from both high school and
a couple during undergrad, I took part in medical service trips to parts of rural
Appalachia, more specifically parts of eastern Kentucky, eastern Tennessee, and
southwestern West Virginia. While I was there, I assisted doctors, physicians
associates, nurses, the list goes on in providing medical care to hundreds of
disadvantaged Americans, as many, if not all of them fell well below the poverty
line. It was truly heart wrenching to see how these people had to live given
their circumstances and the medical conditions from which they suffered. There was
an utter lack of healthcare available to them in these towns that were once
booming epicenters of coal production, as the nearest medical clinic was often
times over an hour away. While there is an entirely larger conversation to have
about the plethora of socioeconomic, educational, and infrastructural disparities
that occur in these regions of the U.S., the medical inequities and the poor
access to healthcare seem to be at the top of this list.
Appalachia
has higher mortality rates in seven of the leading causes of death in the United
States including, heart disease, cancer, COPD, injury, stroke, diabetes, and
suicide (Smith, 2021). While working in the clinics, there also was not a day
that went by, where we did not see a coal miner come in from a 12+ hour shift
covered from head to toe in soot from one of the few mines still open, complaining
of respiratory problems (mainly asthma). Upon treatment of these young men,
chest x-rays and cardiorespiratory testing were performed, among other things, and the
results would shock anybody as entire portions of their lungs were filled with ash
and dust. Many of them men admitted that they had not seen a doctor in years,
as missing a day of work to go to a medical clinic meant no pay that day, which
they often times could not come to sacrifice. Besides those working in the coal
mines, many individuals we treated were pre-diabetic or already diabetic,
obese, suffering from atherosclerosis, or CVD. In conversations I had had with
these patients, many of them said it was cheaper to buy soda than it was to buy
milk and getting fresh fruits and vegetables was like stumbling upon a gold
mine. As a result, processed foods and beverages loaded with additives, sugar,
and other harmful ingredients seemed to be the basis of peoples diets, as I had
one mom tell me, “I’m afraid to give my son (who was 2-years old) water, as I
do not know if it will be safe for him to drink, so I give him soda and juice
instead.”
All of
this presents an extreme ethical dilemma to those of us living in the United States,
as many often think, “people don’t live like that in the U.S.” but in all
honesty, I have seen worse poverty within the borders of our country than I
have seen in parts of Africa and South & Central America. The average
life-span in Eastern Kentucky is on average 8-9 years less than the national
average of 79 years of age, due to severe lack of proper healthcare, dramatic
food deserts, poor working conditions, and widespread lack of working opportunities
(Jackson et al., 2017). This thus raises the question of “what can I do
and how can I help” these individuals who quite literally have nothing while many
of us, myself included are very fortunate to live the lives we do. I believe that
as a future healthcare professional, we all ought to campaign and advocate for equitable
access to healthcare in areas where people need it the most and make it our
mission to not only serve our own communities but those within our country who
have faced medical disparities. Serving communities in parts of the country like
those mentioned, I believe will help one become a better physician in learning
about the plights these people face, while concurrently learning more about diseases
and illnesses that disproportionately affect certain regions of our country.
References
Jackson,
B. E., Oates, G. R., Singh, K. P., Shikany, J. M., Fouad, M. N., Partridge, E.
E., & Bae, S. (2017). Disparities in chronic medical conditions in the
Mid-South. Ethnicity & health, 22(2), 196–208.
https://doi.org/10.1080/13557858.2016.1232805
Smith,
E. (2021, January 6). Human Rights in Appalachia: Socioeconomic and health
disparities in Appalachia. Retrieved November 23, 2021, from
https://sites.uab.edu/humanrights/2021/01/06/human-rights-in-appalachia-socioeconomic-and-health-disparities-in-appalachia/.
I have lived my entire life as part of a rural community, and I work for an ambulance service in Limon, Colorado that is the only advanced life support service for an area of nearly 200 miles. We are responsible for covering ALS calls from Limon all the way to Kansas, and more often than not we only ever have one unit on call at a time. Our service is severely underfunded, and yet we are responsible for providing life-saving care for amounts of time 4-5 times longer than first responders working in a city. This is merely a drop in the bucket of how underfunded and underrepresented rural areas are when it comes to adequate and equal healthcare opportunities. In fact, I found a study that says rural clinics rely almost exclusively on state and federal funding, which are subject to major change based on policies year after year (Beatty et al., 2020). The discrepancies in life expectancy exist not only for the reasons you listed above, but I can tell you from personal experience that I have worked with patients who have absolutely no education when it comes to what healthcare is or what it entails. Most rural citizens are so low on the socioeconomic gradient that they can't afford basic healthcare, or nutritional food, or other basic necessities of life. Speaking as someone who has lived in a rural community my entire life, I can tell you that not much has changed in my area over the years, and if this is indicative of other rural areas around the country, this should be a major cause of concern for people going forward.
ReplyDeleteBeatty K, Heffernan M, Hale N, Meit M. Funding and Service Delivery in Rural and Urban Local US Health Departments in 2010 and 2016. Am J Public Health. 2020 Sep;110(9):1293-1299. doi: 10.2105/AJPH.2020.305757. Epub 2020 Jul 16. PMID: 32673110; PMCID: PMC7427251.