Monday, November 29, 2021

No Stakes vs. Low Stakes

 Emma Winfree

As all of us Physiology students know, the exams in both Anatomy and Physiology classes are no cakewalk. It takes a lot of preparation and studying to do well on these exams, and they are both very rigorous classes with difficult material. In a study done on students over a three-year period at Marieb College, performance on Anatomy and Physiology I and II exams was observed. As stated in the paper, “practice exams are a proven tool to increase retrieval of information long-term” (Reuter, 2020). They compared the results of students who took no-stakes practice exams to study for the actual lecture exams, as well as low-stakes practice exams, and taking no practice exams at all. 

            The results showed that those who took the low-stakes exams were more likely to take them than those who took the no-stakes exams. As a college student who already took Anatomy and is currently in Physiology, this does not surprise me. If these low-stakes exams can help my grade in the class, even just a small amount, I would also take them. Since they are giving me credit, I would also study for them and take them more seriously than a no-stakes practice exam. As to be expected, those who took the low-stakes exams did significantly better on actual lecture exams 1, 2, and 3 than those who did the no-stakes practice exams. The shocking part of this study is that those who were earning credit for these low-stakes practice exams did worse on the final exam than those who were not earning credit by taking the no-stakes practice exams. 

Although the differences in scores between the two groups on the final exam were not significant, it is still shocking. Those who took the low-stakes practice exams did significantly worse on the final exam than the rest of the exams. This could be due to the final being cumulative, and they didn’t retain the information as well over a long period of time as those who took the no-stakes practice exams. It could also be because the low-stakes takers didn’t study as hard for the final as the no-stakes because they had better grades going into the final exam. 

            Given the results of this study, professors may want to consider giving low-stake practice exams before actual exams. The study proves that they do help improve test scores and overall grades in the class. The question is why did it not help on the final exam? Was the final exam significantly harder than the rest of the exams, or are no-stake practice exams better for overall retention of information?

 

Reuter, Peter. “Low-Stakes vs. No-Stakes Practice Exams in Anatomy and Physiology Classes: Which One Works Better?” HAPS Educator, vol. 24, no. 2, 2020, pp. 21–26., https://doi.org/10.21692/haps.2020.010.

What is love?

 




Million Dollar Man - Bionic Baroreceptor Replacement!

         With BP changes, our body must compensate to maintain homeostasis. Baroreceptors are critical in a reflex arc that elicits vasculature changes in response to altered arterial BP. The baroreflex can act via autonomic, endocrine, or behavioral alterations to achieve this compensation (Sved, A.F., 2009). If arterial BP drops, then the barorceptors will signal release of vasopressin (an antidiuretic) and increase thirst sensation, effectively increasing cardiac output. As you can imagine, maintaining homeostasis in blood pressure is critical to normal functioning and staying conscious. Without a quick response from the baroreflex, common actions such as standing would be insanely difficult. However, maladaptive pathology can lead to impaired functioning of the reflex and result in orthostatic hypotension (Sato et al., 2002).

        Fortunately, if you are suffering from a failure of your baroreflex, research has been done to develop a bionic therapy. Sato et al. (2002) worked with mice to determine if the technology would work. They found that their bionic model could return normal function in rats. Dr. Sato continued his research with another group in 2006 to progress the bionic baroreflex system (Yamasaki et al., 2006). In this study, 33 patients with orthostatic problems were given the bionic replacement. Orthostatic hypotension was tested by a thigh tourniquet and release. The baseline pressure after release of the tourniquet was 17 +/- 3 mmHg average decrease of arterial pressure in the first 10 seconds and in the first minute, the decrease was 25 +/-2 mmHg. With the bionic baroreflex system, the decrease was only 9 +/-2mmHg within the first 10 seconds and only 1 +/-2 mmHg for the first 50 seconds (Yamasaki et al., 2006).

        This artificial control of the reflex has incredible pressure control and has positive implications in the realm of personalized medical therapies. If you have a condition that affects your pressure, your cardiologist could potentially install a bionic system that could virtually fix your pressure problems and in some cases improve your pressure control. Each bionic implant can be tweaked to match your body’s system so even hypertension could be treated. Derivatives of this technology have been used for years and greatly improve quality of life for many. However, with every therapy, cost is still a major factor. Until politics meets medicine, we might never see access of this technology for all. If the technology or the procedure becomes cheaper, then maybe we will see a significant reduction in hypertension and subsequently, cardiovascular diseases.  


Sato, T., Kawada, T., Sugimachi, M., & Sunagawa, K. (2002) Bionic technology revitalizes native baroreflex function in rats with baroreflex failure. Circulation, 106, 730-734. https://doi.org/10.1161/01.CIR.0000024101.77521.4D

Sved, A.F. (2009) Blood pressure: baroreceptors. Encyclopedia of Neuroscience. 259-264. https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-008045046-9.00468-X

Yamasaki, F., Ushida, T., Yokoyama, T., Ando, M., Yamashita, K., & Sato, T. (2006). Artificial baroreflex. Circulation, 113, 634-639. https://doi.org/10.1161/CIRCULATIONAHA.105.587915


Should Patient Autonomy Always be Respected?

In the United States, one out of three births are performed by cesarean section (c-section) making it one of the most common surgical procedures. Cesarean section is delivery of the baby by creating incisions in the mother’s abdomen and uterus ("Cesarean Birth", 2021). Many women will agree to have a cesarean section to ensure the likelihood of delivering a healthy baby. However, there are women who refuse cesarean delivery regardless of the obstetrician's recommendations due to worry of postoperative pain, concern of cost, cultural and religious beliefs, and incomprehension of the situation (Desphande & Oxford, 2012).


The doctrine of patient informed refusal presents a dilemma in situations where the fetus’s life is at risk and the pregnant woman refuses to undergo medically indicated cesarean delivery although it assures the well-being of her fetus. Some argue the patient’s informed refusal should be respected and the patient autonomy takes preeminence, however others argue the biomedical ethics beneficence and justice and doing no harm to the viable fetus can justifiably overrule the informed refusal of surgery (Desphande & Oxford, 2012).


As discussed in our MSBS seminar class, language and cultural differences can lead to difficulties in communication. A report revealed, in the United States 81% of the women who turned down cesarean delivery were black, Hispanic or Asian; 44% were single, and 24% did not speak English as their first language, and 100% were treated in a teaching-hospital clinic or were receiving public assistance (Desphande & Oxford, 2012). To better navigate this dilemma, obstetricians and the clinical team ought to take the time to understand the reason and motivation behind the patient’s refusal and ensure the patient understands the situation while preserving the trust of the patient-physician relationship. Obstetricians are ought to empathetically encourage the patient to agree to cesarean birth if the risk of morbidity or mortality to the fetus is high. As Dr. Campisi mentioned, it is a disservice to know only one language when pursuing the medical field. As aspiring healthcare providers, we ought to pursue a second language to better understand and serve our patients.


References

Cesarean Birth. (2021). Retrieved 30 November 2021, from https://www.acog.org/womens-health/faqs/cesarean-birth


Deshpande, N. A., & Oxford, C. M. (2012). Management of pregnant patients who refuse medically indicated cesarean delivery. Reviews in obstetrics & gynecology, 5(3-4), e144–e150.

Self-driving cars, are they ethical?

 Not a physiology post but this is cool:


AI has always been a hot-topic for as long as I can remember, as with anything that sounds futuristic that we as a society are closer to attaining and harnessing for our own gain. I remember my father showing me the movie ‘iRobot’, when I was a kid, and legitimately being afraid of these autonomous, humanoid, beings, that slowly turned against Will Smith over the course of the film. But even before this feature film of 2004, the 80s and 90s were strewn with references to robotic overlords. Blade Runner in 82’, The Terminator in 84’, and The Matrix in 99’ all point towards imminent war, chaos, and destruction as technology advances and our greed gets the best of us. Time after time, Hollywood has taken the opportunity to orientate AI as an end game for humanity. Machines reaching their final destination and eventually eclipsing us entirely, much less being within our iron-fisted control. I think that this stigma in pop culture has brought us to the position we see ourselves in today. Take self-driving cars, for example. According to a study done at the Transportation Research Institute at the University of Michigan, in 2015, autonomous vehicles, or AVs got into more accidents than conventional vehicles. The rate was actually surprisingly high with AVs coming in at 9.1 crashes per million miles driven, and conventional vehicles at 4.1 crashes per million miles driven. But the problem here is that there is still too little data to do a fair analysis of absolute safety between AVs and regular cars. And to put things back into perspective, every time a Tesla, or other AV gets into a minor fender-bender, it seems that there is a news story surrounding the incident pointing out how dangerous self-driving cars are. I think that part of the issue is people’s need for control and aversion to giving it up. We see that a machine that is still in development makes a mistake, and immediately think back to the movies of our childhood and write them off as dangerous and unhinged vehicles, when in reality they are simply a new technology that has room to grow. I think that numbers this promising, so early in the life of these vehicles show a safe a bright future for EVs. I think there is a lot of good to come of self-driving cars, and I don’t think we should let emotions get in the way of progress, so long as it is safe.

http://websites.umich.edu/~umtriswt/PDF/UMTRI-2015-34_Abstract_English.pdf

The gene editing debate may not be about ethics after all

Ever since I was a child, I had an immense fascination with our cosmos. My dream of becoming an astronaut actually made me consider studying physics in college. Although I gave up on that dream, I still love learning about our universe because it allows me to contemplate ideas greater than myself and to think about “tomorrow”. 

With recent news of CRISPR technology and advancements in gene therapies, the ethical debate of “should we play god” has emerged. As I think about these ethical issues, I’m conflicted. Part of me agrees that we should be cautious about the downstream effects of altering our genes, but honestly, part of me doesn’t really care. 

Our culture, especially in the US, only thinks about the next election cycle or the next fiscal quarter. Our consciousness needs to change into one that values the “tomorrow”. Whether you think about it or not, the reality is that this planet of ours has a set lifespan. If we as humans are lucky enough to fix climate change or prevent nuclear fallout, we still need to get off this planet. Although our sun only has enough hydrogen to burn for 5 billion years, it will become inhospitable to life as it starts to expand over the next billion years. 

The inevitable is that if humanity persists, we will need to become a space-bearing civilization. Unfortunately, we weren’t evolved to live in the high radiation/low gravity of space, and as such, we will have to alter our genome. Just this year, astronauts aboard the International Space Station successfully used CRISPR to repair double-stranded DNA breaks in yeast (Stahl-Rommel et al., 2021). Issues with space travel and how we alleviate them have become more apparent. The famous NASA Twin Study compared astronauts Scott and Mark Kelly to see what changes occur after one twin spent a full year in space. The results showed decreased body mass, telomere elongation, and genome instability, among others; evidence that humans will need to be altered to survive outside planet Earth (Garrett-Bakelman et al., 2019). 

In my mind, this ethical debate about “playing god” is futile in the grand scheme of things. Genetic modification should not be a question of “if”, but a question of “when”. If we want to survive as a species, we must take a hard look at ourselves and be honest about where we are going. 


Citations: 

Garrett-Bakelman, F. E., Darshi, M., Green, S. J., Gur, R. C., Lin, L., Macias, B. R., McKenna, M. J., Meydan, C., Mishra, T., Nasrini, J., Piening, B. D., Rizzardi, L. F., Sharma, K., Siamwala, J. H., Taylor, L., Vitaterna, M. H., Afkarian, M., Afshinnekoo, E., Ahadi, S., Ambati, A., … Turek, F. W. (2019). The NASA Twins Study: A multidimensional analysis of a year-long human spaceflight. Science (New York, N.Y.), 364(6436), eaau8650. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.aau8650 

Stahl-Rommel, S., Li, D., Sung, M., Li, R., Vijayakumar, A., Atabay, K. D., Bushkin, G. G., Castro, C. L., Foley, K. D., Copeland, D. S., Castro-Wallace, S. L., Alvarez Saavedra, E., Gleason, E. J., & Kraves, S. (2021). A CRISPR-based assay for the study of eukaryotic DNA repair onboard the International Space Station. PloS one, 16(6), e0253403. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0253403

Should you drink with your children?

 During the time between 2018 and summer of 2021, I dated a guy whose parents were very open about drinking around and with their younger kids. At first, I didn’t think much of it but with time my perspectives changed as I watched his parents allow his 17-year-old daughter get relatively drunk during holidays and even just regular “party weekends”. So, for this post I will discuss the ethics behind underage drinking with parent consent/supervision.

Throughout the U.S., underage drinking with parent supervision is allowed in 29 states including the state of Colorado (States that allow underage consumption, 2020). This is more than half the country. Quick fun fact, 6 states legally allow underage drinking without parent consent. Does this mean that because it is legal it is ethically right? Based on data found by Aloi et al. (2021), this may not be the case. This study has shown that alcohol consumption in teens increases their chances of developing alcohol use disorder (AUD) in the adult years (Aloi et al, 2021). AUD in turn has shown to reduce or weaken the ability for decision making. This occurs by a reduction in the neural pathways involved in the reward prediction error or the ability to distinguish between the expected value of a given stimuli and the perceived value.

So, the ethical questions I ask are, should there be laws enabling underage alcohol consumption even when supervised or with parental consent? And if not, then should parents be held accountable for the possible consequences this may bring to their children?

Until the age of 18, children are under the protection and supervision of their parents. In the case of a medical or lawful emergency, parents often have a say in the final decision taken and children will often rely on their advice. Parents who allow their teenage kids to drink may or may not be aware of the negative consequences this could bring to them later in life. This leads to concerns in the beneficence of these adolescents whose parents allow them to consume alcohol. In addition to this, parents who enable underage drinking, increase the risk of future harm or to their children, therefore decreasing non-maleficence. These topics are hard to address, whether you are a friend of a parent or a parent who may allow for this. However, it is important to become aware and educate oneself on the possible consequences as to prevent harm to those we love. 

Aloi, J., Crum, K. I., Blair, K. S., Zhang, R., Bashford-Largo, J., Bajaj, S., Schwartz, A., Carollo, E., Hwang, S., Leiker, E., Filbey, F. M., Averbeck, B. B., Dobbertin, M., & Blair, R. (2021). Individual associations of adolescent alcohol use disorder versus cannabis use disorder symptoms in neural prediction error signaling and the response to novelty. Developmental cognitive neuroscience, 48, 100944. https://doi-org.dml.regis.edu/10.1016/j.dcn.2021.100944

States that allow underage (under 21) alcohol consumption - drinking age - procon.org. Drinking Age. (2020, February 18). Rettrieved November 30, 2021, from https://drinkingage.procon.org/states-that-allow-under-21-alcohol consumption/.

Why does acid reflux get worse after treatment?

Chronic acid reflux can be annoying and uncomfortable. Many times, when people are struggling with chronic acid reflux their healthcare prov...